Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 is a model electroactive bacterium whose extracellular electron transfer (EET) pathway includes a sequential network of c-type cytochromes that span the inner membrane, periplasm, and outer membrane. While electrochemical studies revealed the critical role of outer-membrane cytochromes in mediating both outward EET from cells to external surfaces and lateral biofilm conduction across cells, the specific functional role of the periplasmic cytochromes in these processes is less understood. Dissecting the contributions of the periplasmic components has been challenged by the complexity of the periplasmic cytochrome network and the inherent variability of native biofilms, which confounds the electrochemical comparison of cytochrome mutants. Here, we overcome these limitations with a synthetic biology approach combining targeted deletion of genes encoding key periplasmic cytochromes with light-induced biofilm patterning to create uniform, geometrically defined biofilms on electrodes for robust electrochemical comparisons. Voltammetric measurements of patterned S. oneidensis mutant biofilms confirmed the essential role of periplasmic cytochromes in facilitating outward EET, a contribution that becomes apparent when flavins are present to accelerate interfacial electron transfer between outer-membrane cytochromes and the electrode. In contrast to this crucial role in routing outward EET across the periplasm, electrochemical gating measurements of lateral biofilm conductivity revealed that the periplasmic cytochromes do not contribute to long-distance electron transport along cellular layers bridging electrodes. These findings provide new insights into the role of periplasmic cytochromes in S. oneidensis, and distinguish their contributions to routing outward EET across the cell envelope versus biofilm conductivity.